High Court Acquits Juvenile in Aggravated Defilement, Child Trafficking Case

3 minutes, 8 seconds Read
Justice Lubega observed that the prosecution had failed to call the girl’s mother, who was the person who had received the information directly from the victim.
The High Court in Mbale has acquitted a juvenile accused of aggravated defilement and trafficking in a 16-year-old girl after finding that the prosecution had failed to present sufficient evidence linking him to the alleged offences.

Justice Lubega Farouq delivered the ruling on November 19, 2026, in Criminal Session Case No. 0213 of 2026, involving Musunku Devis, who had faced two charges under Uganda’s laws.

The accused had been indicted for aggravated trafficking in children, contrary to sections 2(1)(a) and 4(a) of the Prevention of Trafficking in Persons Act, and aggravated defilement under Section 116(1) of the Penal Code Act.

According to the prosecution, the alleged offences occurred in August 2025 in Bunyiny Town Council, Kwen District.

On the first count, the prosecution alleged that Musunku and other suspects still at large recruited, harboured or transported the 16-year-old girl through abuse of power or her vulnerable position for purposes of sexual exploitation or child marriage.

The second count alleged that he performed a sexual act with the girl at Muyenga Lodge in Bunyiny Town Council during the same month.

Musunku denied both charges, prompting a trial in which the prosecution presented only one witness, Chebosoi Martin, alongside medical examination reports for the complainant and the accused.

In his testimony, Martin told court that his wife, Chebeti Sofi, had informed him that their daughter was pregnant. He said the girl had reportedly identified Musunku as the person responsible for the pregnancy.

Martin further testified that he reported the matter to police but that the girl subsequently disappeared from home and her whereabouts remained unknown.

However, during cross-examination, Martin admitted that his testimony was based on information he had received from his wife rather than his personal knowledge of the events.

Justice Lubega observed that the prosecution had failed to call the girl’s mother, who was the person who had received the information directly from the victim.

The judge consequently ruled that Martin’s testimony amounted to hearsay and could not be relied upon to establish the accused’s participation in the alleged offences.

Citing Section 59 of the Evidence Act, which requires oral evidence to be direct, the judge noted that the prosecution had not demonstrated that the testimony fell within any recognised exception to the hearsay rule.

The court further observed that although evidence from a victim is generally preferred in sexual offence cases, the evidential gap can, in appropriate circumstances, be addressed through testimony from someone to whom the victim directly narrated what happened and identified the alleged perpetrator.

In this case, however, the prosecution relied on third-hand information, which the judge found inadmissible for proving the essential elements of the charges.

District Officials Remanded Over Alleged Sh136m PDM Funds Fraud

Lawyer Accuses Mufti Mubajje of Directing Sh3.5bn Land Compensation Withdrawals

The court nevertheless retained Martin’s testimony regarding the girl’s age, which was supported by a medical examination report indicating that she was 16 years old when examined on May 25, 2026.

Justice Lubega concluded that the remaining evidence was insufficient to establish the essential ingredients of aggravated child trafficking and aggravated defilement or to sustain a conviction if the accused were required to defend himself.

The judge accordingly found Musunku not guilty on both counts and ordered his immediate release unless he was being held on other lawful charges.

The ruling was delivered in chambers in the presence of the juvenile offender and lawyers representing both sides.

Editorial note: The court document identifies the district as “Kwen District” and the town council as “Bunyiny”. These spellings have been retained as they appear in the ruling and may need verification before publication.

https://youtu.be/3HsHEU09t7s
Let others know by sharing

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!